WAS MASARYK THE MASTERMIND OF WILSON'S FOURTEEN POINTS, MANEUVERING THE UNITED STATES INTO WORLD WAR I? THE PROFILE OF A HUMANIST, PHILOSOPHER, REVOLUTIONARY, TRAITOR, STATESMAN, OR OPPORTUNIST By Karl Hausner
In this review, we will ask many
questions and have some answers. How did a person of poor parents attain
the success of becoming a professor of philosophy and later president?
In addition, how could a person, who was brought up speaking the German
language, and enjoying German culture, a man, who obtained all his education
in German, become a Nationalistic Czech and the first President of Czechoslovakia.
We shall also ask how Masaryk
could get access to the American political and financial elite. We will
ask whether he influenced President Wilson, as Wilson contemplated, entering
World War I, or whether Wilson and his political and industrial elite used
Masaryk as an instrument to destroy the two largest monarchies in Europe,
Austria/Hungary and Germany.
THOMAS GARRIGUE MASARYK 3.7.1850-9.14.1937
During the year 2000, the Czech
Republic celebrated the birth of Thomas G. Masaryk, who was the first President
of Czechoslovakia. In 1948, when the Communists took over the country under
Klement Gottwald, he was brought into discredit. His monuments were removed,
because Masaryk was not a Marxist.
However, in the year 2000, a new
statue was erected in Prague. During the dedication, the American Secretary
of State, Madeleine Albright, who was born in Prague, was the guest of
honor. A great deal is known about Masaryk, though much more is kept secret.
Both, the Encyclopedia Britannica and the German Brockhaus say very little
about his ancestry, upbringing, his frequent changes of religion, language,
political outlook, jobs and his activity in the United States.
Who actually was this man who is claimed to be a great humanist, philosopher
and statesman?
Most know that he was the first
President of Czechoslovakia between 1918 and 1935, when his long time associate,
Edward Benes, became President of that country. Masaryk died as a
very wealthy person in the prominent castle LANY in Bohemia.
During the celebrations in Prague
and, of course, during the entire era of postwar Czechoslovakia, the truth
about Czech politicians, active during World War I and World War
II, was distorted and this continues to be the case even today. Although
the Czech Republic is now part of NATO and wants to join the European Union,
the truth and even justice is far from being implemented. Yet, it was Masaryk
who claimed that truth alone was the foundation of his newly created country.
The average Czech, and for that matter
most Americans, know that Prague is the Capital of Czechoslovakia, respectively
the Czech Republic, but very few know that this city was really not a Czech,
but a Bohemian city. Seven hundred years ago, it was even the Capitol of
the Holy Roman Empire of German Nation under the Emperor Karl IV, a Frankonian.
Czech Nationalism and Communism have kept such information away from the
Czech people and the world. For example, the fact, that the oldest German
University, the Karl's University, was founded in Prague 700 years ago.
Up to the beginning of World War I, most cities in the present Czech Republic
were heavily populated by German people, and in many instances they were
the majority. All these cities, except Tabor) were founded not by Czechs,
but by Germans. These two nations were living together for almost 1500
years, generally in harmony. The exeptions, of course, were the Hussite
Wars, the time of the first Czechoslovak Republic between 1919 and 1938
and, of course, after World War II, when practically all Sudeten Germans
- 3.5 Million of them - were brutally expelled from thenhomeland. More
than 240 thousand Sudeten Germans were killed during that process.
MASARYK, THE PERSON
His mother was the daughter of a German Gastwirt (innkeeper) in the old German Town of Auspitz, Moravia. She went to Vienna for a short time and then became the cook of a very wealthy family - the Redlich's - a Jewish family whose language was German. His legal father was an illiterate Hungarian Slovak by the name of Joseph Masarik. It was generally accepted, that his biological father was Mr. Redlich. This was rather common, not just in wealthy Jewish families, that young women, who kept the household, also served as mistresses or concubines. After she was pregnant for a few months, she married a much younger illiterate coachman at the Redlich estate, to establish a legitimate family. They married August 15, 1849, however, Thomas was born on March 7, 1850. It was a little kept secret that the biological father was Nathan Redlich, who had from his own marriage three sons, all of whom became well to do. Since Masaryk's mother was German and the Redlich family spoke German, Thomas grew up with the German language. He, in his later years, spoke very highly of his mother, who gave him everything, but he rarely mentioned his legal father or his brothers, or perhaps stepbrothers is a better term.
Nathan Redlich was generous to Thomas
Masaryk and it is well known, that his attorney. Dr. Alois Prazak ofBrunn
(Brno) paid frequent amounts to the Masaryk family for the education of
Thomas. When Thomas entered elementary school, he studied in German. Later,
at the high school in Brunn (Brno), these studies, as well as his university
studies in Vienna and Leipzig, were in German. As late as 1879, his colleague
Penicek had to translate for Masaryk his positions into the Czech language.
He spoke Czech with a strong German accent until his death. Yet, he became
a fanatical Czech nationalist, hating the Habsburgs and perhaps due to
that, everything German, especially the Catholic church.
Later, when Masaryk created Czechoslovakia,
many Sudeten Germans hoped and believed he would be friendly to them because
of his heritage. It is true, that Masaryk recognized that the Bohemian
Germans or the Sudeten Germans were economically and culturally more advanced
than the Czechs.
HIS AMERICAN CONNECTIONS
While Masaryk was studying in Leipzig,
he met a wealthy American music student , Charlotte Garrigue, and married
her. Through this connection, he was exposed to the American financial,
industrial and political elite, especially to the extremely wealthy and
influential industrialist, Charles Crane. He engaged Thomas as a consultant,
and it was through Crane, that Masaryk got to know Woodrow Wilson. Crane
financed Wilson's election and Masaryk's son Jan was an intern at the Crane
empire and later in the Secretary of State's Office under Wilson. He even
married Crane's daughter.
Although the United States had
intensively engaged in the "melting pot" ideology, eliminating the ethnic
grouping in this country, Wilson came up with the Fourteen Points of self
determination for Europe. In the Habsburg Empire, fourteen nationalities,
including Czechs and Slovaks, harmonized relatively well, but Masaryk,
as an extreme nationalist, wanted the opposite. His self determining ideology
appealed to many different American ethnic groups and the Wilson administration.
Thus, the United States entered the conflict, proposing a self-determination
concept for Europe, in other words Wilson's Fourteen Points, which big
business considered good business.
Without the American involvement
in World War I, the nations involved in this conflict would have had to
agree to a less dramatic change. Hitler would have not won power later,
and World War II could have been avoided, as serious historians point out.
HISTORIC REVIEW OF CZECHOSLOVAKIA AND THE CHECH REPUBLIC
Much has already been written about Thomas
Garrigue Masaryk. After a dispute, stretching over several years to find
a suitable location for a new Masaryk monument, the American Secretary
of State, Madeleine Albright, finally unveiled his statue at his 150th
birthday at the Hradschinplaza in Prague. Who actually was this man, portrayed
as a great humanist, philosopher and politician? The world knows that he
was the First President of the 1918/19 newly founded, multinational State
of Czechoslovakia, created at the expense of the Austrian-Hungarian Monarchy
and the various ethnic groups, especially the 3.5 million Sudeten Germans
and the close to one million Magyars.
On the presidential banner he
had embroidered in Czech on one side, in Latin on the other, his motto:
"The Truth is Victorious!"
The entire history of Bohemia,
Moravia and Sudeten-Silesia (in the following only Bohemia), for centuries
settled by Germans and Czechs, some Jews, who were mostly German speaking,
was woven by the Czechs in mysticism and poetry, purposive fairy tales
and stories, beginning with forefathers, Czech and Libusche. In this diction,
Kail IV is only spoken of as the King of the Czechs (incorrectly), crowned
in Zaachy. The fact that he was the Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire of
German Nation, and Zaachy, mentioned as the old imperial city Aix-la-Chapelle,
is conveniently withheld. The Czech Hussites, who ravaged innumerable,
mostly German villages, towns and monasteries, murdering thousands of people,
warded offfive crusades to the Holy Land, until they destroyed themselves
in 1434 at Lipany. With that, the reignofterTorofoverl5years,ended.From
1620until 1920,theCzechsa]legedlyhadtoendure300years of darkness, though,
during the same time, Bohemia became the highest developed province of
the monarchy and perhaps Europe. It should be stated, that Bohemia
is incorrectly translated as Chesky by Czech nationalists. Bohemia = Czech
is wrong, but is maintained to this day. The assertion, that formerly many
Czechs only spoke German is untrue! Further contortions and portrayals
could be added.
Similarly, Masaryk was given ahalo
until 1948. When the Communists took over) he was considered a traitor
by the Czech Communists. So was and is history being bent accordingly.
MASARYK'S BIOGRAPHY
He wrote of himself that he was
a Slovak, later a Moravian, finally a Czech. Was he not rather of German
nationality and Austrian citizenship? He declared his mother Theresia to
be a German from Auspitz (Hustopece). She was the daughter of a German
innkeeper and butcher, who later was the Mayor of Auspitz. After several
years in Vienna, she came to Goeding in 1849 to a well-to-do Jewish family
by the name of Nathan Redlich to be their personal chef. She only spoke
German, as the Redlich family also conversed in German. On August 15, 1849,
she married the Hungarian Slovak by the name of Josef Masarik who worked
for the Redlich's as coachman. He could neither read nor write and was
a full 10 years younger than Theresia. When Thomas was born on March 7,
1850, it was an open secret in the Redlich family, that Nathan Redlich
was the biological father. He already had three sons with his wife: Alois,
Ignaz and Adolf. All three of them became very successful. The son of Adolf,
Josef Redlich, was for many years Secretary of the Treasury in Vienna.
When Masaryk became President, he offered him the Ministry of Trade - respectively
Finance in Czechoslovakia. Noted historians stated that Masaryk was a "child
of love". It is known, that the lawyer of the Redlich family, who later
became the Minister in Bruenn, Dr. Alois Prazak, paid significant subsidies
to the mother of Masaryk for his education. Masaryk himself and the Redlich
family were good friends all their lives, especially with Josef Redlich
and his wife Alice. A Redlich was also mayor of Goeding. Masaryk hardly
mentioned either his father, Josef Masarik, or his brothers Martin and
Ludwig, always emphasizing his mother, to whom he felt he was indebted
for everything, even though, she was German and he was a "Czech". He pursued
his study in Auspitz, Bruenn, Vienna and Leipzig) studying exclusively
in the German language. Still in 1879, a Czech student, Penizek, translated
much for him into the Czech language. Therefore, it is understandable that
many German-Bohemians saw in Masaryk a person to be trusted. He in turn
felt a certain respect for the Germans, especially because of their economic
achievement and culture.
When he stood for the truth in
the fight about the Koeniginhofer' and Gruenberger manuscripts, which were
unmasked to have been forged, Czech hostility almost caused him to emigrate
to the U.S.A. His lectures at the Czech University were in the Czech language,
even though, he had a strong accent.
The life of Masaryk was rich in dramatic
events, which apparently shaped his work and his personality. One of those,
for example, was his defense of the Jew, Leopold Hilson, from Kuttenberg,
falsely accused of murder and sentenced to death, whom he was able to save
before the man was executed. This was widely discussed in American Jewish
circles. Therefore, in 1907, Justice Louis D.Brandeis of the U.S. Supreme
Court, a good friend of Woodrow Wilson, organized a "large reception" for
Masaryk with the Jewish community in New York. Large financial donations
were collected for him. Many other financial contributions were made to
him and in 1918, he received for the not yet existing Czechoslovakia, aloan
of $ 10,000,000 from Wall Street.
Masaryk noted for himself: "Especially
in America, the Leopold Hilson case proved to be a great success."
Politically, Masaryk made a name
for himself through his writings, among others "The Czech Question" and
"Russia And Europe". He further became known through his intervention in
the Agramer (Zagreber) Process of 1909 against Serbian rioters, insofar
as he proved the documentary evidence to be falsified.
A stroke of luck for him was his
marriage to Charlotte Garrigue on the 15th of March in 1878 in New York.
The father of Charlotte (whose parents had emigrated to Denmark via Germany
as French Hugenotts) was at the time in training with the publisher Brockhaus
in Leipzig, from where he emigrated to America. He became wealthy and in
the end owned the largest fire insurance company of the U.S.A. The family
had eleven children, eight daughters and three sons. In 1870 he visited
Leipzig with part of his family. Charlotte remained there for three years,
studying music. In June of 1876, Charlotte returned for another visit.
At that time, Masaryk resided with the Goering family, and so luck took
its course. After the wedding, the newly-weds lived in Vienna in
a financially modest situation. Here, on March 3, 1879, their daughter
Alice wasbom.andonthefirstofMay inl880,their sonHerbert.LaterinPrague,onthel4thofSeptemberin
1886, another son Jan entered the world, and on the 25th of May in 1891,
their daughter Olga. The older son Herbert died at the early age of 35
on the 15th of March in 1915. Yet, his father did not come from Switzerland
to attend the funeral.
A positive financial turn for
Masaryk did not come until 1884.-A rich student, who died in Berlin, willed
him his fortune. With that, the Masaryks' were able to move into a villa
according to his status and to pay off his debt in Vienna. Shortly thereafter,
Charlotte's parents died, so they also received a large inheritance from
that side of the family.
HOW MASARYK INFLUENCED HISTORIC EVENTS
In Prague in 1896, thanks to his connections
and those of his wife's family, Masaryk made an acquaintance with the extraordinarily
wealthy American industrialist and diplomat Charles Crane (18581931), with
whom he established a very close friendship. Crane became a large financial
donor to Masaryk and financed, in a large scale, the then Czech and Slovakian
resistance against the Habsburg Monarchy in the U.S.A. Through the English
man Henry W. Steed and Robert Seton-Watson, they cultivated direct contacts
with governmental circles in London. In 1912, Crane financed the election
campaign of Thomas Woodrow Wilson (1856-1924), who, in 1913, became the
American President. Crane became his Counselor in the White House. Thus,
Masaryk established a very effective Czech lobby with the new administration.
The son, Richard Crane (1882-1938), during World War I, was Private Secretary
to the Secretary of State and later Foreign Minister of the U.S.A. From
1919-1922 Richard Crane \vas Ambassador in Prague. The other son, John
Crane, became Masaryk's secretary in 1922. Jan Masaryk, the son of Thomas
G. Masaryk, worked from 1907-1913 at the branches of the Firm Crane in
Bridgeport, Chicago, and from 1924-1929 was married to Crane's daughter,
Leatherby.
Jan Masaryk was, from 1919-1920, Charge
d'affaires at the State Department, that is Certified Counselor at the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Czech Government and afterwards, until
1939, Czech Ambassador in London. Because England did not accept the Protectorate
status in Bohemia and Moravia, he maintained his role. While at the side
ofBenes, he became the Foreign Minister in exile and later from 1945 to
1948 in Prague. During the Communist take-over, he lost his life at the
so called "Prague window dumping", details of which remain unclear to this
day.
In 1945, Jan Masaryk gave to his
colleague Josef Koerbel, born in 1909 in Geiersberg (father of U.S. SecretaryofStateMadeleineAlbright),thevillaattheHradschinplaza
No. ll,nowtherestaurant"ULabuti". Previously, the very-well-to-do German
owner, the Nebrich family, had to leave their villa at a moments notice
with only hand-carried belongings. In 1948, the Koerbels', who in the meantime
called themselves Korbel, took with them in their escape to the U.S.A.,
the entire inventory, including valuable oil paintings. The German "Spiegel"
commented on this (17/1999).MadeleineAlbright and her brother are thus
far reftising to return the stolen property to the Nebrich sisters.
Another important, downright fateful
personality in the web of Czech-American connections built mainly by Masaryk,
was Emanuel Viktor Voska. He was born in Kuttenberg (Kutna Hora) on the
4th of November in 1875 and emigrated to America in 1894. The trained stone-sculptor
became a construction entrepreneur, bought several marble quarries and
quickly attained considerable wealth. This man, hardly mentioned by historians,
was also politically very active, intimately close to Charles Crane, and
worked extensively with Czech militant Associations in America and the
Wilson Government. He was the leader of the Czech "Sokol", a socialistic
association, and the association of Free Thinkers. He was also a publisher
of several magazines in the Czech language. In 1902 he became acquainted
with Masaryk. In 1910 and 1912 he invited Masaryk and organized at his
own expense, exclusive lecture tours in the U.S.A., at which time considerable
sums of money were collected for Masaryk's effort to destroy the Habsburg
Empire.
During that time there were, besides
Voska, Stefan Osusky, an attorney in Chicago (1889-1973), and Vojta Benes
(1878-1951), who had emigrated to the U.S.A. in 1915. They were both active
in the Czech resistance in the U.S.A, and were able to collect large contributions
for Masaryk. In the fall of 1914, there began the close collaboration of
Masaryk with the brother of Vojta, Edward Benes (1884-1948), and somewhat
later with M. R. Stefanik (1880-1919). Both lived in Paris and cultivated
contacts with the highest French, Italian and English circles. Thus, Paris
was the European Center of the Czechoslovakian underground organization,
which stood in close connection with the "Maffia" of Prague, led by KarelKramar
(1860-1937).
PREPARING FOR WORLD WAR I AND THE DESTRUCTION OF THE AUSTRIAN/HUNGARIAN EMPIRE
In June 1914, Voska came to Prague to
see Thomas Garrigue Masaryk and other Czech politicians to consult in the
event of a possible war. On his return trip at the end of August in 1914,
he traveled from Holland to London. There he gave to W. Steed of the English
Secret Service, Masaryk's detailed report concerning the political situation
in Austria-Hungary. After Voska's return to the U.S.A., he advanced the
Czech Association of the American Czechs and Slovaks. He organized actions
for the support of the Czech resistance against the Austrian-Hungarian
Monarchy and financed it decisively from both his own sources and also
through donations from associations. In 1914/1915 he founded a courier
service between the native and the foreign Czech resistance. Already instituted
by Masaryk, he could skim dependable sources directly from the Viennese
Court and forward this valuable, up-to-date information, to the Western
Allies. For this, he was generously financed by the English Secret Service.
At times, he engaged two couriers monthly, en-route between Vienna, Prague,
Paris, London, Chicago and Washington. Until 1917, St. Petersburg was also
included. In 1915, he founded with Czech countrymen in the U.S.A., counterespionage
against the German and Austria-Hungarian espionage service.
While in Switzerland, on the 6th
of July in 1915, Masaryk declared war against Austria-Hungary in the name
of the yet only aspiring Czechoslovakia. Masaryk encouraged Czech and Slovak
soldiers to desert. Sometimes, even entire units up to the regimental level
deserted from the Austrian/Hungarian frontlines against Russia, the Balkan
and Italy. They became known as legioneers. For that, Masaiyk, Benes and
some others, were sentenced to death in absentia for high treason by the
Austrian court. Later they were pardoned by Emperor Karl, the successor
of Franz Josef.
After the declaration of war by
the U.S.A. in the spring of 1917, Voska was called into the American Army
with the rank of captain, and he became the liaison officer between the
Czech legions and the U.S. Army. From April until September of 1917, he
was in- Russia (at the same time as Masaryk). There he organized the American
espionage service (Slaw Press Bureau). In 1918/1919 he was in charge of
the Central-European espionage section of the American General Staff.
Voska, from the beginning of the
war, informed the decision- making personalities of the U.S.A. and England
about the Czech resistance, and through his contact with Masaryk, also
acted as personal liaison between Masaryk and President Witsond). In 1919,
he became consultant for the American delegation at the Peace Conference
in Paris.
Conference partner to the Czech
delegation under the leadership ofKarel Kramar was Dr.
Edvard Benes. This delegation was counted among the victorious powers.
Therefore, it had in addition to this status, its direct authorities in
the circle of the American President. (On June 3,1918, Czechoslovakia was
recognized as an Allied power, and its frontiers were demarcated according
to Masaryk's outline). The French side was led by Clemenceau, whose hatred
of the German-Austrian war enemy was well known. Also the propaganda activity
of the Benes Group in Paris, and the politicians of the western powers,
was supported by the counsel of Masaryk, Benes, Stefanik and Voska. American
politicians often were not able to differentiate between Bosnia, Bohemia,
Slovenia and Slovakia. Thus, Benes especially, was able to operate with
falsified maps relative to the settlement area and false statements as
to the number of Sudeten-Germans and Magyars.. He useda numberofl.6Millioninsteadofthefactualfigureof
3.6 Million Sudeten-Germansandwellover
a billion other ethnic groups. The Sudeten-German representation
under Rudolf Lodgman Von Auen, (1877-1962), as part of the German-Austrian
delegation, was from the outset in a losing position. Thus, the Austrian-Hungarian
Empire, in the dictate of St Germain was destroyed, which would have been
the foundation of United Europe. "The U.S. Senate never ratified the Treaties
of Saint-Germain and Versailles and thus. World War II was a continuation
of these conflicts.
From 1919, Voska lived as a businessman
and entrepreneur in the CSR. Politically, he was active in the Social-Democratic
Party, and published several articles about the Czech resistance during
World War 1. In 1936/1937 he supported the Communist
Revolution in Spain. On the 16th of March in 1939 he was arrested by the
Gestapo, but for "reasons of health" was soon released. In June of 1939
he was able to return to the U.S.A.
In 1940 Voska's book "Spy and Counterspy"
was published, which he had written together with W. lrwin. From 1941-1945
he was in Turkey as an American intelligence officer (colonel), returning
to the CSR in 1945. He was incarcerated by the Czech communists in 1959,
he died shortly after his release in 1960 and wasposthumouslyfullyrehabilitatedin
1991.
The close and direct connection
and the immediate influence of the Czech emigrants, respectively such dependable
authorities as Charles Crane and Voska upon the Wilson-Govemment, obviously
played a substantial role in the entry of the U.S.A. into World War I in
1917. The Czechs and their friends were interested in the total defeat
of the Central Powers, especially Austria-Hungary. Due to the absence of
Russia
on the battlefield following the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution, they saw
their goal in great danger. The American Declaration of War in 1917, and
the later deployment of 1.2 Milhon U.S. troops, gave Masaryk and his group
new confidence. When, on the 18th of October in 1918, President Wilson
declined to accept the last peace offer of the Austrian Emperor Karl, it
elicited an immense jubilation among Czech Nationalists. On the same day,
Masaryk proclaimed in Pittsburgh the Foundation of Czechoslovakia. This
was the deathblow for the Austrian-Hungarian Monarchy. Czech politicians
claimed that President Wilson and the Allies in Central Europe would not
have acted without the consent of Masaryk. With that, the U.S.A. attained
a position of world power.
Masaryk, through his manifold
fund raising actions, meanwhile had substantial financial means at his
personal disposal. Without difficulty, he was able to undertake numerous
travels with his daughter Olga between America and Europe up to the Far
East of Russia. In addition, he provided for the pay of his collaborators,
couriers and agents, including the legionnaries. In 1923, he gave each
of bis family members and also Edward Benes 2.05 Millions Kc. He bought
a house in Auspitz for his legal father, and for his "stepbrother" Ludwig,
he equipped a printing shop. Considerable amounts were also transferred
to various friends,
publishers and foundations. In 1932, he deposited 10 Millions Kc into
the Masaryk Foundation. (At that time, the country was in a depression).
During the course of his life, Masaryk
evolved from a young German-Austrian scholar, who only advocated a larger
Bohemian autonomy, into a champion, intellectually and linguistically,
for a Czech national state. He demanded the Czech claim for everything
within the borders of the future state up to "unseren Deutschen"(our Germans).
In his message on the 23rd of December in 1918, he described them as having
come into the country as "Immigranten und Kolonisten"(immigrants and colonists).
In an interview on the 10th of January in 1919 he indicated, one would
for "diese Landesfrernden" (these strangers in the country)... perhaps
create a certain modus vivendi (way of life), and should they prove to
be loyal citizens, it might even be possible for our parliament to grant
them, at least in the arena of public education, a certain autonomy. In
areas settled by Germans he said: "Besides, I am convinced, that a very
swift de-gennanization of these areas will take place". It is imaginable
that he would expect for the Germans in the country, or at least for many
of them, to become Czechs, as he did himself.
As it emerges out of the memoirs
of Herbert Hoover, Wilson's successor in the American Presidency, Masaryk
was even willing to forgo a part of Western Bohemia, in order not to get
so many Germans into the new state. He asked Hoover "to influence President
Wilson to the effect that the President might oppose the integration of
this area, because it would place him (Masaryk) into a difficult situation
with his colleagues if he were to do it himself. Less Germans in the land
would have meant, that even with a relative autonomy of the ethnic groups,
the Czech majority vs. the sum of all the others would have been secured.
However, in the negotiations at Saint-Gennain, the French prevailed, especially
Clemenceau, who "insisted upon leaving as many Germans as possible in Czechoslovakia
in order to weaken Germany". Now, Masaryk and Benes stressed especially
the thesis of a Czech-Slovakian nation in order to insure the majority
through the inclusion of the Slovaks. Masaryk also had the confidence ofM.
R. Stefanik, the Slovak leader. Yet he, because of President Wilson's 14
points regarding the people's self-determination, was only agreeable to
begin with a cantonal federation (similar to Switzerland) of states for
a probationary period of ten years. Through this substantial demand in
the name of his Slovakian people, he became antagonized with Edward Benes.
This was "the reward" for having introduced Benes into the highest political
circles in France and Italy. Also for organizing the Czech and Slovak legions
who, independent of their questionable actions in Russia, served as proof
for the Czech war participation and lhus, the new nation was counted as
a victorious power. It became the key to the foundation of the state.
After the conclusion of the "peace
conference" of St. Germain, most of the suggestions were ignored by Benes
and Masaryk. Czechoslovakia, actually should have become a non-military
state with guaranteed self-determination, fashioned in the character of
Switzerland. (Neutrality and cantoral authonomies.) The first demonstration
of power by the Czechoslovak state was the military occupation of the Sudetenland
and Slovakia by the Czech Legions, crushing all resistance by force. The
national minorities had to mourn their first dead. (March 4, 1919 over
50 German demonstrators, including women and children were shut to death
and many were wounded).
The only one in opposition to
be taken seriously in this matter, was the Slovak Stefanik, a French officer,
and in the end a General. His deadly "accidenfon the 4th of May in 1919,
eliminated him. (TTlis was most likely an assassination, like that of Jan
Masaryk in 1948.)
The bodily decline of the elderly
Masaryk, who was becoming increasingly blind and senile, allowed Benes
an altogether free hand, and the great tragedy took its course, making
the 3.5 Million Sudeten Germans and the minorities strangers in their own
homeland. Certainly not what was promissed, a country like Switzerland.
MASARYK & AMERICA - TESTIMONY OF A RELATIONSHIP
From the Introduction of Subject book by George J. Kovtun,
Library of Congress, Washington 1988.
In 1902, Masaryk traveled to America
at the invitation of the philanthropic industrialist Charles R. Crane,
who had established a foundation for Slavic lectures at the University
of Chicago. By a happy coincidence, Crane turned out to be a friend ofWoodrow
Wilson's, a fact that was to serve Masaryk well until 1918. Two yearselapsedbetweenMasaryk'sfirstandsecondjourneystoAmerica.During
tliisperiod,he became a well-known figure in Czech public life. He was
assigned to the new Czech university in Prague as a philosophy professor,
after which he founded a periodical. Athenaeum, in which he practiced what
he called "scientific criticism". He pubhshed several books on the problems
of Czech history and politics, and on social and philosophical questions.
In the years 1891-93 he represented the Young Czech Party in the Austrian
parliament in Vienna.
During Masaryk's second visit in the
USA (which lasted three months) Masaryk made an extended tour of the Czech
immigrant centers, visiting New York, Chicago, St. Louis, Baltimore, Cleveland,
Cedar Rapids, and other cities. He had not yet presented a political program
of independence, but speaking on a variety of subjects (religion, socialism,
Czech literature and history) he clearly contributed to Czech and also
Slovak national aspirations.
On his third visit, in 1907, Masaryk
came to America as a Czech intellectual whose political role had received
flesh impetus. He began his journey shortly after having been elected a
member of the Vienna Parliament for a second term, representing the small
Progressive Party, which he helped create in 1900. He arrived in New York
on August 7 and stayed in America for two months. He participated in the
Congress of the Religious Liberals in Boston and again visited the Czech
immigrants. His appearances before the Czech-Americans culminated in a
series of speeches delivered at the Association of Czech Freethinkers in
Chicago.
It was his fourth and last visit
to America that made history. He came at the beginning of May 1918, as
the leader of the Czechoslovak Liberation Movement, and left in November,
already the first President of Czechoslovakia (without any vote by the
Czech or Slovak people). MasarykhadleftAustria-Hungary
in December 1914, traveling to the then neutral Italy. From there he moved
to Switzerland and to France, and in October 1915 settled down in Great
Britain. He worked for the cause of a "free Czechoslovakia" in the West
European Allied capitals. When the Tsarist autocracy was replaced by a
provisional republican government in Petrograd in March of 1917, Masaryk
went from England to Russia, where he hoped to recruit thousands of volunteers
from the ranks of the Czech and Slovak prisoners and deserters of war for
his army. In Russia he succeeded in organizing the largest Czechoslovak
volunteer army (other Czechoslovak armies were built in France and Italy).
Masaryk and his representatives concluded several agreements concerning
the neutrality of the Czechoslovak army in Russian domestic conflicts,
and its later transfer to France, where reinforcements were sorely needed
against the German onslaught. (Contrary to these agreements, Czech legions
robbed and even destroyed Russian villages).
Recognizing the growing importance of
the United States, which finally declared war on Austria-Hungary in December
1917, Masaryk traveled to America. He crossed European Russia and Siberia
in a train. After a brief stay in Japan, he sailed from Yokohama to Vancouver,
and arrived in Chicago on May 5,1918.
His political aims become evident
in the second section of the book, ("Lobbying for an Independent State"),
consisting mainly of documents which show the American Czechs and Slovaks
campaigning for a program of self-determination and independence, as well
as Masaryk's own explanation of his goals. In the third section of the
book, ("Masaryk in the Spotlight") Masaryk, now on his fourth and most
important visit in America, is clearly in focus. Newspaper reports and
diplomatic memoranda remind us how he was viewed by contemporary witnesses
and how he acted on the political scene. In the next two sections ("Masaryk
and American ideals" and "Masaryk and Wilson") we see from Masaryk's declarations,
statements, and letters how he valued the American democratic tradition,
and Woodrow Wilson as the interpreter of this tradition. Clever as he was,
he became the mastermind behind Wilson's Fourteen Points of Self-determination
for Europe, which was in direct contradiction to Wilson's " melting pot"
ideology in the United States.
Masaryk owed his invitation to
lecture at Chicago University in 1902 to the recommendation of the French
Slavist Louis Leger and to his knowledge of English. Before his second
trip to the United States he was visited by one of the founders of Slavic
studies in America, Leo Wiener who wrote the first report about Masaryk
for the American press.
During his last visit in the United
States before the First World War in 1907, Masaryk earned the special attention
of the Association ofGalician and Bukovinian Jews which held a public gathering
in his honor.
Before returning to the United
States in September of 1914, Voska offered himself to Masaryk as a courier
for his contacts with the Western countries.
ln March of l915, most of the scattered Czech groups were
united in the Bohemian National Alliance (BNA). In October of the same
year, the BNA formally entered into an agreement with the Slovak organization,
the Slovak League of America, to pursue jointly the aim of political independence
under the banner of self-determination.
Before the Czech and Slovak immigrants
could develop their anti-Habsburg propaganda effectively, Masaryk sought
assistance from individual American sympathizers, among whom Charles R.
Crane was the key person. Masaryk informed Crane in a letter written on
February 3, 1915, from Geneva, that the Czechoslovak revolutionaries "prepare
the extreme steps a nation can and must do to get her independence", and
asked for financial help. Crane furnished material assistance and arranged
for the first interview by an American correspondent with Masaryk during
the war.
Not all the people who were willing
to recommend Masaryk to Wilson's attention believed in the feasibility
and success of Masaryk's aim. The American journalist Norman Hapgood, a
friend of Wilson's, sent a copy of one of Masaryk's memoranda from London
to the White House on January 29, 1917, but said in his accompanying letter:
"I myself am not for an independent Bohemia, but I think Professor Masaryk
deserves a hearing".
The first recognition of Masaryk's
idea was given by France in the time of the premiership of Briand, who
promised assistance to the Czech people. When President Wilson sent his
inquiry to the Allies concerning their program, their response included,
among other things, the independence of the Czechoslovak nation. That was
solemnly promised by the Allies.
MASARYK IN THE SPOTLIGHT
Officially Washington received
Masaryk as an expert on Russia who, it was hoped, would throw some new
light on the enigmatic developments in that disorganized country. His idea
of psychological warfare, which made use of the antagonism between the
Slavic peoples of Austria and the German-oriented government was, however,
not always understood by the diplomats.
When Breckinridge Long (Third
Assistant Secretary of State) on September 17,1918 wrote his second memorandum
dealing with Masaryk, the United States had already recognized Masaryk's
movement as the de facto government of Czechoslovakia. The subjects of
the conversation between Long and Masaryk included economic assistance
and the situation of the Czechoslovak Legion in Russia. Masaryk used the
opportunity to reemphasize his concept of the independence of small nations
as a necessary and useful principle of international order, which he did
not actually plan to implement in Czechoslovakia, though in America he
did not admit to this.
In October 1918, Masaryk prepared
the Czechoslovak Declaration of Independence, which was clearly inspired
by the American Declaration of 1776. (What a propaganda scheme it was).
The Czechoslovak Declaration (whose official version is in English), was
drafted by Masaryk, edited with the assistance of several American friends,
and released by Masaryk on October in 1918, as the final solemn act
of his revolutionary movement.
MASARYK AND WILSON
The first message, addressed by
Masaryk directly to Wilson, arrived in Washington on December 13, 1917.
Masaryk sent a telegram from Kiev after he had heard the United States
declaration of war on Austria-Hungary. He was convinced that America's
full participation in the war against the Central Powers was the logical
conclusion of a necessary development. (Now, the United States supports
the creation of a European Union, which existed, in a small way, during
the time of the Austrian-Hungarian Empire, which had to be destroyed in
1919).
The first meeting between Masaryk
and Wilson is described in two documents. Shortly after his visit to the
White House on June 19, 1918, Masaryk wrote a hasty note in Czech, summarizing
the main points of the conversation. The note was published in a Czech
collection of documents in Prague in 1953. For his own record and to inform
his friends, Masaryk also wrote, or dictated an English note on his meeting
with Wilson. One copy of the note was handed to Richard Crane, the son
of Charles R. Crane and private secretary to Robert Lansing.
After it had become obvious that
the Czechoslovak soldiers in Russia were entangled in a conflict with Bolshevik
units (because they were robbing peasants), Masaryk asked the American
Government for assistance. Wilson, while maintaining his negative view
concerning a military intervention in Russia, was finally impressed by
the appeals of France and Britain and agreed to dispatch several thousand
American troops to the area of Vladivostok, not to intervene in Russian
affairs, but to safeguard "the country to the rear of the westward-moving
Czecho-Slovak Legionnaires." Masaryk was thankful for the decision.
When Masaryk came to see Wilson on September
11,1918, the question under discussion included assistance for the Czechoslovak
Army in Russia, the recent agreement between the Czechoslovak National
Council and the British government, and the possibility of a Japanese supreme
command over foreign troops in Siberia. (Mostly Czech and Slovak legionnaires).
ln0ctoberl918, MasarykbecametheheadoftheMid-EuropeanUmon,ag,roupofCentralEuropean
representatives, residing in the United States. On October 26, 1918, the
Mid-European Union, convening in Philadelphia, issued a "democratic" manifesto
called the "Declaration of Common Aims". Masaryk used the opportunity to
send the declaration to Wilson to explain his concept of European reconstruction
(Wilson's Fourteen Points).
ThelastmeetingbetweenMasarykandWilsontookplaceonNovember
15,1918.Masaryk,fearing a loss of prestige for the American President,
advised Wilson against becoming personally involved in the detailed European
questions at the peace conference. His apprehension is shown in a Czech
note written in his hand and published in facsimile in Jan Herben's biography,
T.G.Masaryk. (Wilson, in poor health, had became a liability in the upcoming
dictates of peace).
From Masaryk's book Svetova Revoluce
(The Making of a State): "I begun my personal relations with President
Wilson relatively late. I arrived in Washington on May 9, 1918, and met
Wilson for the first time on June 19, the invitation being conveyed by
Mr. Charles R. Crane. In all mv political campaigns abroad it has been
mv method to try to influence statesmen through public declarations, articles,
and interviews. And before I saw the President. I spoke with people with
whom he was in contact and who had a certain influence on him". (This,
in his own words, was the corrupt nature of Masaryk).
THE NEW EUROPE
In his work, Masaryk expressed
the need to explain why he had begun his revolutionary activity. At the
heart of The New Europe lies Masaryk's demand to create an independent
Czechoslovak State. This, however, was not an isolated goal. Masaryk also
demanded an independent Poland and Yugoslavia, and an entire zone of independent
nations between Germany and Russia. The political reconstruction of Eastern
Europe was considered by him "the principal problem in the aftermath of
the war". He invokes the principle of national self-determination, but
he also sees, that in many territories with mixed population, the borderlines
between the states could not be based on ethnographic factors (A total
contradiction to self determination). The new states in which the "small
oppressed Slavic" nations will exercise their political freedom will be
created within historical and natural borders. Inevitably, these states
will include national minorities which will be guaranteed their civil rights
by an international agreement, and possibly by an international arbitration
tribunal for national questions. (This he never permitted and certainly
did not plan).
Twenty years later. World War
II broke out, as a direct consequence of the stupidity and injustice at
Versailles and Saint Germain. Czechoslovakia broke apart twice, first in
1938/39 and then in 1992. Three and a half Million Sudeten Germans were
made homeless in 1945/46, over 240 thousand killed and the rest expelledmadditiontoafewhunderthousandfromSIovakia.Between
1948and 1989, CzechsandSlovaks had to endure self-inflicted tyranny by
Communists. Now, extremely poor nations are not willing to accept U.S.
House Resolution No. 562 of October 13, 1989 to permit the return or compensation
of those expelled. Yet, they eagerly wanted to join NATO and now the European
Union, the very constellation, which existed in a small way, in the Habsburg
Empire, which Masaryk, with the help of the Western Allies, in 1919 destroyed.
In this essay, we cannot expand
deeper reviewing the situation in Poland and Yugoslavia. Especially the
latter has become a land of hostilities with no real peace and harmony
in sight. When will the Government of the United States stop reconstructing
the world by supporting revolutionaries and terrorists? In view of September
11,2001, this would be the only way to protect our people from such "Freedom
Fighters", or better terrorists.
Had World War I ended differently,
the Bolshevik Revolution would have not likely succeeded, and World War
II would have been prevented. The tyranny, which Stalin forced on Eastern
Europe after World War II, for over forty years, would have not taken place.
Not to mention the Cold War, the ten trillion dollars, which the American
taxpayers had to pay and the twenty six additional wars, which Americans
had to fight, just to mention Korea and Vietnam and the problems in the
Middle East and Africa. If we had stayed neutral, as our Founding Fathers
intended, and certainly did not envision this kind of foreign policy, we
would not have become the target of international terrorism. Will we learn
from the history, or will we continue the course of "reconstructing and
policing''the world? Can we win the war against terrorism if we continue
to support terrorists as was Masaryk?
Bibliography:
1. Dr. Ferdinand D. Katzer: "Was ueber T.G.Masaryk und Boehmen oft
im Dunkein bleibt", Sudetendeutsche Zeitung, November 24, 2000.
2. Prof. Dr. Josef Kalvoda: "The Genesis of Czechoslovakia", New York
1986. 3. George J. Kovtun: "Masaryk & America", Library of Congress,
Washington 1988. 4. Charles Richard Crane, the National Encyclopedia of
American Biography, page 221-222. 5. Woodrow Wilson, the National Encyclopedia
of American Biography, page 169-170. 6. Edith Boiling Gait Wilson, the
National Encyclopedia of American Biography. 7. "Bohemia", Deutsche Zeitung,
"Die erste Botschaft Masaryks" (Masaryk's first message), 23. December
1919.
8. Emanuel Victor Voska and Will irwin: "Spy and Counterspy", Doubleday,
Doran & Co. Inc., New York, 1940.
9. David F.Houston: "Eight years with Wilson's Cabinet 1913 to 1920",
Doubleday, Page & Company, New York 1923.
Prepared for presentation at the
Twenty-Sixth Annual Symposium of the Society for GermanAmerican Studies,AmanaColonies,lowa,April
18-21,2002.
Recognition:
The author appreciates and recognizes the important library research ofTitanila Strbova, including translations from Czech language into English and transcription of the manuscript and the translation from German into English by Hans-Jochan Holz.
Karl Hausner 28 Concord Drive Oak Brook, IL 60523-1767 Fax: (630)543-2102 E-mail address: medical@elmed.com